ICT does have its proper place in the classroom
The media are largely ignoring the most significant conclusions of the highly valuable OECD report Students, Computers and Learning: Making The Connection published earlier this week, analyzing the impact of using ICT on student performance.
When reading media reports, the overall conclusion seems to be that the effect of ICT on student performance is disappointing and we should limit its place in the classroom. This Australian newspaper, for example, states that iPads in schools are a waste of money, making it seem as if the report, based on its research results, strongly discourages the use of the iPad to support individual learning tracks.
Fortunately, thanks to the web, everyone has easy access to the report and can verify its claims, methods and conclusions for themselves: http://www.oecd.org/education/new-approach-needed-to-deliver-on-technologys-potential-in-schools.htm.
Contrary to what is claimed in the Australian Courier, this report does not investigate the use of ICT over the past 10 years; it deals with the 2009 to 2012 time period. Tablets were not yet being used in schools at that time, nor were the curricula and didactics associated with their use. The OECD report simply does not deal with iPads.
Moreover, the study only involved students aged 15 (born around 1997) who took the PISA test. The questions on their computer use only pertain to the month preceding the test. This says very little about their home and classroom ICT environment during the previous 10 years.
Nor does the report discuss the impact of ICT on the performance of students born around e.g. 2003, let alone those born in 2009 or after, most of whom will have acquired considerable ICT literacy using a smartphone or tablet even before they start school.
While the exact numbers differ per country and no research results are available for the Netherlands yet, a study conducted among 15-year-olds in 2012 shows that students who report moderate computer use perform slightly better than those who do not use computers. Yet its outcomes also indicate that more frequent use of computers in the classroom leads to students performing less well than those who use ICT moderately.
So what are we to make of this? Should we hold back on the use of ICT, as suggested by Truijens?
The OECD report answers that question unambiguously, both in the press release on its site and in its foreword. The OECD website header states: “New approach needed to deliver on technology’s potential in schools”. This could have been my line.
In the Foreword to the report, the Director of the OECD Directorate for Education and Skills writes that “[…] we have not yet become good enough at the kind of pedagogies that make the most of technology; that adding 21st-century technologies to 20th-century teaching practices will just dilute the effectiveness of teaching.”
He adds that “we need to get this right in order to provide educators with learning environments that support 21st-century pedagogies and provide children with the 21st-century skills they need to succeed in tomorrow’s world.”
The Director concludes by calling on those responsible for education to make sure teachers acquire the skills that support change, so they can start designing and implementing new types of education. He also pleads for sustainable financing to back up this change.
While media reports create the impression that the report rejects the type of education that I am propagating, the recommendations of the OECD Director exactly match the principles that led us to found a new type of school in 2012, de Steve JobsSchool, also known as the iPad School.
Having created a new type of education, facilitated by the iPad as a tool, our schools are real-life examples of the OECD vision. We use 21st-century pedagogies to prepare children for life after 2025.
Our teachers naturally play a central role in this, even though that’s a different role from the one played by teachers in 20th-century schools. They are not chiefly following the steps in courses with pre-published teaching materials, prevented by group structure from accommodating the differing capacities and needs of individual children. Our teachers are coaches who focus on each student’s individual development plan.
Using tablets to make the most of the interactive and adaptive capabilities of apps and other digital training programs focusing on the three Rs, our teachers spend their time helping individual students tackle their challenges. This is facilitated by the reorganized classroom format and curriculum which means teachers are no longer grading student work till late. Our children are given more freedom and flexibility, encouraging them to develop important non-cognitive skills such as creativity, collaboration, critical thinking, media maturity and ICT literacy.
Our teaching practices are based on the motto stated in the report: “Technology can amplify great teaching but great technology cannot replace poor teaching.” The developments that quite a few commentators choose to ignore are taking place in our schools: Great teaching can be complemented by the intensive use of technology. While ICT should not be an objective in itself, it is an excellent tool for facilitating differentiated instruction, enabling all children to make the most of their individual talents and opportunities.
